Antigone and ismene compare and contrast essay

Antigone and ismene compare and contrast essay

ISMENE Is e'en this boon denied, to share thy lot? Find'st thou pleasure in these gibes? Antigone, however, scorns Ismene's belated attempt at righteousness: ISMENE O sister, scorn me not, let me but share Thy work of piety, and with thee die. ANTIGONE Claim not a work in which thou hadst no hand One death sufficeth. ANTIGONE Ask Creon, he's thy kinsman and best friend. ISMENE What would life profit me bereft of thee? Though she agrees morally with Antigone’s decision to bury Polyneices, she is afraid to risk her own life: ISMENE I scorn them not, but to defy the State Or break her ordinance I have no skill.

If Antigone were a bit more like her sister, this wouldn't be a tragedy at all. ISMENE Why taunt me? ISMENE My poor, fond sister, how I fear for thee! What's the point of bringing more sorrow? In Antigone, however, we see that Ismene's loyalty only extends so far. Antigone and ismene compare and contrast essay.

ISMENE O say if I can help thee even now. Before we close the book on Ismene, we'd just like to recognize that the strong will that her sister is often praised for is also the thing that causes three suicides. However, she's just not gutsy enough to stand up for her beliefs. Wherefore should'st thou die? Ismene's argument at the beginning of the play is that their family has suffered enough. The girl ends the play with her life intact, but her self-worth in shreds.

To top it all off, their two beloved brothers have just murdered each other. Ismene is Antigone Lite. I will go alone To lap my dearest brother in the grave. We can see Ismene's point. ANTIGONE 'Tis a sad mockery, if indeed I mock. ANTIGONE O waste no fears on me look to thyself.

ANTIGONE No, save thyself I grudge not thy escape. ANTIGONE A specious pretext. She shows devotion once more when she returns with Antigone to Thebes. Is Ismene really that bad for just wanting to finally live in peace? The courage to stand beside her sister does eventually come to Ismene. ANTIGONE Yea, for thou chosed'st life, and I to die.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *